COMMUNITIES

Hidden Groups

Hidden Groups enables communities to safely include sensitive (ex. health support group) or audience-specific conversations (admin-only planning). In a community, every subgroup was visible to every member. Giving group admins control over visibility made Communities suitable for more of the groups people already relied on, while community admins retained oversight.

WhatsApp screens illustrating the Hidden Groups experience

IMPACT

12% feature adoption

OF THRIVING COMMUNITIES CREATED SINCE LAUNCH HAVE AT LEAST ONE HIDDEN GROUP.

64% positive sentiment

PERCENT OF COMMUNITY USERS RATED HIDDEN GROUPS A MUST-HAVE OR NICE-TO-HAVE

+1.3% group adds

LONG-TERM INCREASE IN GROUPS ADDED TO COMMUNITIES.

+1.6% group creates

LONG-TERM INCREASE IN GROUPS CREATED IN COMMUNITIES.

RESULT

Hidden Groups gave communities a way to keep sensitive work, academic and admin-only conversations together without exposing them to everyone else. The rollout had no lasting regressions and was tracking toward the goal of 11,000 additional thriving communities.

PEOPLE
PROBLEM

Every group added or suggested in a WhatsApp Community was visible to all community members. Membership approval could restrict who joined, but admins had no way to hide a subgroup.

This could make people hesitant to bring sensitive or audience-specific groups into Communities.

Sensitive conversations need privacy.

Every subgroup was visible to the entire community, limiting space for health support or private discussions.

UXR INSIGHT

Interviews highlighted the importance of privacy and safety. Research supported keeping hidden groups permanently hidden to protect those expectations.

Some conversations are for a specific audience.

Admin planning and other restricted discussions need privacy while preserving community admin oversight.

PRODUCT CONSIDERATION

Membership approval controls who joins, but doesn’t hide the group from other community members.

People need to understand what “hidden” means.

Visibility must be clear before people share sensitive information.

UXR INSIGHT

12/14 participants immediately understood the crossed-out eye icon with the “Hidden group” label. “Hidden groups” and “Group visibility” tested best for comprehension.

DESIGN
PRINCIPLES

  1. Empower members, keep admins in the loop. Members can create safe spaces to talk, while admins can still see hidden groups and manage their community.
  2. Protect privacy and safety. Only invited members and community admins can see a hidden group. Once hidden, it cannot become visible again, protecting members’ expectations of privacy.
  3. Make it easy to understand. Admins and members should know exactly how hidden groups work, so they trust them with what matters.

SOLUTION

New setting in creation and linking flows

I added a Group visibility setting to two flows: (1) Group admins can make a new group hidden when they create it in a community, or (2) make an existing group hidden when they link it to a community. By default, the setting is set to visible.

Creating a hidden group

Linking an existing group

Group visibility setting

Group visibility dialog with Visible and Hidden options and a note that the setting is permanent once the group is added.

PRODUCT DECISION

A one-way door. Once a group is hidden, it stays hidden. Making it visible again would expose group details to the wider community. That decision placed the setting at the point of creation or linking, before the group appears in the community.

The Privacy team strongly supported the one-way setting in our Safety & Integrity review. UX research also recommended it after interview sessions showed how important privacy and safety were to members.

Visually differentiating hidden groups

I explored various ways to mark a hidden group in the community and Chats tab. I landed on the simplest treatment of showing an icon appended on top of the group profile photo.

Nine chat-row explorations for marking hidden groups with text or icons, including the chosen icon appended to the group photo.

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

Disappearing messages already uses an icon on the group photo, so I used the same pattern for Hidden Groups. When both settings apply, the Hidden icon takes precedence because group visibility is more important to communicate for member privacy.

I collaborated with my content writer and UX researcher to test the wording and icon with participants. 12/14 research participants immediately understood the crossed-out eye icon with the “Hidden group” label; “Hidden groups” and “Group visibility” tested best for overall comprehension.

Clarity about hidden groups

It was important to ensure group admins and members understood the group’s visibility and what it meant for their privacy. I reinforced this across the chat and Group Info with visual indicators, a system message, and clear explanations of who could see and join the group.

  1. Hidden group indicator on top of the group profile photo
  2. System message informing all group admins
  3. Text in subtitle in Group Info
  4. Group visibility row in Group Info

What each person ‘sees’

Visibility follows a person’s relationship to the group. Hidden groups appear in the community and chat list for their members, while other community members cannot discover or request to join them. Community admins can still see them for awareness and moderation, but need an invitation to participate.

Creator & invited member(s)

Community navigation showing the hidden group for a member of that group.Hidden-group row visible to invited members, with the hidden icon on the group photo

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

Members of the group see it in the community with the hidden icon. Invite links still work, so they can share it flexibly.

Everyone else in the community

Community navigation for a member who has no access to the hidden group.

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

For anyone else in the community, the group never appears, anywhere.

Community admin

hidden admin communityHidden-group row visible to community admins, labeled Recently added and Invite required

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

Community admins can still see hidden groups in the “Groups you can join,” section (and other surfaces in the community) for awareness and moderation.

Admins can see, but can’t join

Community admins retain responsibility for the whole community. They can see hidden groups, contact a group’s owner to learn more, and remove a group from the community when necessary. They cannot join or request to join without an invitation, preserving the group’s privacy while keeping community management possible.

Hidden group in the community

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

Community admins can see hidden groups for awareness and moderation, even when they aren’t members.

Group join preview

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

The preview explains why an invitation is required and lets admins message the group owner for more context.

Manage groups

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

Community admin(s) can remove hidden groups from the community at any time, like any other group.

Pending groups

DESIGN CONSIDERATION

The review queue identifies hidden suggestions before admins approve them.

RESULT

Hidden Groups rolled out cleanly with no regressions and grew thriving communities in line with its goal. People used it for work and academic groups, surprise planning and admin-only chats.

REFLECTION

What’s planned next

A community-level switch. Some communities, especially more top-down ones, may not want or need hidden groups at all. However, we had no strong signal in UX research but this highlighted the benefit of building incrementally. There is a constant tension of providing the right controls vs. overloading admins with options.

Preventing screenshots. Research participants worried about people screenshotting hidden groups. I looked at how Netflix, Instagram and Telegram handle this as a starting point.

Revisiting the one-way door. If research and dogfooding showed admins needed more flexibility, letting group admins switch visibility could be reconsidered.